I met him three years ago the night my girl dragged me to a club in midtown on a Wednesday night. I was working at Starbucks part-time then and didn’t have a real job, so I could do things like staying out til 5am Thursday morning. Still, I’m not a fan of any club, but Jen, Cutie McBarista and I had decided to go for 80s night.
Not long after I’d had my first drink I was spotted by this rather good-looking dark brown man. He was soft spoken, but aggressive. Friendly, with a nice smile. And he did nothing to hide the fact that he had been interested the minute he saw me. I flirted, then disappeared – I’m not the hook up in the club type and to me there was no other reason to meet a man there other than to hook up.
Two more drinks later I ran into him again and he tried changing his approach. “Let me take you to dinner. I want to know you,” he’d said and I’d laughed, but I certainly was flattered. While this was in the height of my serial dating days, I’d still met most of my 4-6 dates/week online, so I was unfamiliar with this approach. I liked it. I gave in. I was that girl making out with a random dude in the club.
We went on our first date a couple days later and had an awesome time. He was better than I could have imagined. Very sweet, yet with a serious swagger. He dressed nicely, could hold a very intelligent conversation, was affectionate and most of all – was completely enamored by me. I was smitten. The date ended at Piedmont Park, where I took him to my favorite hill and we sat looking at the skyline of Atlanta while he kissed me softly.
This was just the beginning. I cooked for him, he cooked for me, we spent afternoons on blankets reading books in the park. He was everything I thought I wanted. I turned him into a Starbucks lover and he’d sit on the patio with me and my friends and won over their hearts as well. He was great.
Looking back I can’t quite remember what it was that made me break things off with him. Perhaps it was the place I was at in my life and knowing he could easily become something totally permanent and that was scary? Perhaps it was my immaturity and wanting to run around with my friends and not commit to anything. I don’t know.
I started getting gamey. Cancelled on him when we had plans and avoided his calls. I justified it to Jen on the Starbucks patio by saying that “I know it can’t be right if I’d rather be sitting here drinking coffee with you than out with him.” That was enough right then.
“I can’t do this anymore,” I told him and it was obvious he was crushed. He kept trying to find ways to see me and went as far as to show up at my Starbucks one day when he knew I’d be sitting out there on the patio with Jen. I was livid. How dare he invade my space!
After that I got a little mean. I wasn’t very nice in my text responses to him, but he persisted until 2 months later when he asked if I wanted him to leave me alone and I said yes. He did just that. That was three years ago.
Over the past three years he would randomly send me messages – “hope you are doing well” or “Happy birthday”. Things like that. I always wondered how he remembered my birthday, so that made me a little happy, but I brushed it off. I’d entertain the texts until he’d ask to see me and then I’d cut it off again. I couldn’t go there again.
Logistically we are a nightmare.
Four months ago he sent me a text and I must have been bored or lonely, because I entertained it and eventually agreed to meet him for a drink. In the end I knew he was still way too into me and cancelled last minute. The texting was sporadic after that. I’d respond, but tried not to give him hope. I didn’t want to be that girl.
Part of me wondered if something could be there. I mean, he was always fun. I enjoyed being around him. He was very good looking.
But I continued to push him away – asking him to please stop texting me again. And he obliged. He never pushed unless he thought I was breaking down and then he was all about seeing me.
And then Friday night. Oh, boy. I’d had a couple glasses of wine and ended up sending him a message. And then he called. And then I found myself agreeing to dinner on Sunday. Oh dear.
In my heart I knew I didn’t want to play games with this man – and he is a man at 43 – but at the same time I knew opening that door could be dangerous. But I had agreed to go and hell…it’s not like I had anything better to do. So I went.
I’d forgotten how good looking he was until I was standing in his living room as he finished getting ready for dinner. And he was so happy to see me I felt like I was jesiis coming for my sheep or something. But it wasn’t over-bearing or annoying. It was kinda nice to feel special like that.
Still, I was unsure about the whole thing and wondering why I was there. Why bring up the past? Why put this man in a place where he could be hurt by me? That’s a lot for me to carry. I’m used to being hurt – I’m not used to hurting people and I just plain can’t stand it.
Dinner was great, but the conversation was slow. I felt like he was looking at me like he was in awe and I don’t do well with that kind of attention. I wanted it to be easier and it was…well, kinda scary still. I just didn’t want to be the bad guy.
After a couple glasses of wine I found myself lightening up, enjoying and just taking it all in. He told me at least 147 times how much he loved and had missed my smile. I blushed every time. I wasn’t just feeling liquid courage good, but I was wondering why I’d let such a good thing go over some silly little details that meant nothing in the grand scheme of things.
Of all the men I’ve dated since him nobody has ever been that open and honest when there’s been a connection. Nobody has been that consistently good. He was. He always was and I saw last night that nothing changed.
But, as I said earlier and as I told him last night, dating him is a logistical nightmare. That’s part of what holds me back. He lives in midtown, I live 30 miles from there in the middle of suburban hell. He’s on the road a lot. He’s 9 years older and not really making the kind of moves I am in life. He’s content in his tiny midtown apartment within walking distance of everything while I’m working 80 hours a week trying to make things blow up financially.
So on paper – he’s 50/50. I always have said that I don’t care about the details. I don’t care if you make 200k and can wine and dine me ala The Heartbreaker if you treat me right. And with him – I know without a doubt he’d treat me right. He would never lie to me or fuck me over. He thinks I’m gold and that’s such a nice change from what I’m used to.
But….
I just don’t know.
Lined up on paper we’re a total mismatch. It doesn’t work. Sitting there next to him last night, though…well, it worked. I love honesty with feelings. I love that he wants me to open up about things I don’t like opening up about. I love that he thinks I’m amazing. But is that all? Because notice I didn’t say I loved anything about him other than how he treats me. That surely can’t be enough.
Against my better judgment we did have sex. And telling him on the phone the other night that part of the reason I was unsure about us was the mediocre sex definitely made him step up his game. My walk of shame this morning was more of a walk of pride, as I’d had a great night. Better than Mr. D could have given me despite Mr. D being the best sex ever. There’s something to be said about sex with someone who thinks you are the end all, be all. It was great.
And then part of me starts thinking about Secret Crush. SC who has been so fickle and flaky. Why would I ever want that over someone who has been consistently good to me? Someone who thinks I own the world and just wants to give me more? How is that possible?!
And why do things like this have to be so hard?